Analysis of Competing Hypotheses
The primary strength of ACH is its diagnostic value. Traditionally, investigators formulated hypotheses and than intuitively selected the preferred hypothesis. Essentially, investigators only collect and consider evidence that supports their preferred hypothesis, i.e., preferred suspect. In turn, the evidence brought forth to support the preferred hypothesis has no diagnostic value. Diagnostic value of evidence cannot be overlooked.
Diagnostic value can be framed as the specific evidence’s value across all hypotheses. Diagnostic value is not the support of all hypotheses, but the explicit support of one select hypothesis. Heuer (1999) asserts that a common experience, through using ACH, is that analyst find favored evidence supporting their preferred hypothesis simultaneously supports several other hypotheses. In turn, the evidence holds no diagnostic value. Heuer (1999) makes a solid determination that diagnostic evidence should drive judgements. Thus, judgements through ACH become highly objective.
Criminal defense investigations are able to meet the following objectives through ACH.
1. Determine specific evidence not only supports the opposing criminal theory but several alternative theories
2. Identify critical evidence based on diagnostic value
5 Ibid, p. 102
West Virginia License Class: Private Investigations Firm
Pennington & Associates Ltd. provides civil and criminal investigation services. Private investigators are available for immediate service in Ohio throughout the cities of Ironton, Portsmouth, Gallipolis, Jackson, Chillicothe, Cincinnati, Columbus, and surrounding areas. Service is immediately available in West Virginia throughout the cities of Huntington, Charleston, and surrounding areas.